Photos by Michael Durr
Gather 22 hosted its inaugural cocktail competition, the Gather Cup, back in April. This high-energy contest pitted Indy’s top bartenders against each other in a battle of skill, speed and creativity, allowing them to showcase their talents beyond the bar and share their passion for mixology with the Indianapolis community.
At its core, the Gather Cup is a celebration of the talent and creativity in Indy’s bartending scene. “We didn’t want another formal competition. We wanted something that felt fast, raw and real—more ‘Top Chef’ than the traditional cocktail competition,” said Madeline Curtis-Long, director of marketing and events at Gather 22.
Key features of the event included blind spirit draws, mystery ingredient rounds and on-the-spot cocktail creation. Eight local bartenders were carefully selected based on creativity, presence and community impact. “These are people who not only make great drinks but define the culture of Indy’s bar scene,” Long said. The contestants faced off in three elimination rounds, all vying for a $500 cash prize, industry bragging rights and the coveted title of Gather Cup champion. For a Monday night, turnout exceeded expectations, with more than 100 people attending the event.
The evening featured surprising and daring drink creations. “One bartender built a bold mezcal cocktail with savory layers that really stood out. Another used basil eau de vie in a way that felt unexpected but completely balanced,” Long said. The final round featured a mystery absinthe ingredient and had a full room of captivated fans watching. The winner? Juliana Silva from Taxman Brewing took the title. “She was thoughtful, consistent and brought a clear point of view to every round,” Long said. “Her final drink sealed it—intentional, well-executed and unmistakably hers.”
If you missed this year’s Gather Cup, don’t worry—plans are already in the works for next year.
“We’re already planning to make next year bigger and better. We’re thinking more TVs, a satellite bar and more space for the crowd,” Long said. “Juliana will be back to defend her title, and we’re working on launching a formal application system for bartenders who want in.”
So, if you think you’ve got what it takes to be Indy’s best bartender—or want to nominate someone—Gather 22 intends to grow the event. “The Gather Cup isn’t just a competition; it’s a celebration of the people who make Indy’s hospitality scene so special,” Long said. “We’re just getting started.”
Gather 22 is a West Coast-inspired restaurant focusing on fresh, seasonal dishes that reflect cuisines inspired by the owner’s travels. It’s a popular destination in Indy’s Near Northside neighborhood at 22 E. 22nd St. To learn more about the next Gather Cup, apply to compete or nominate a bartender, visit gather22.com.
