Two Sarahs & a Sold Sign

Dynamic Duo Brings Experience, Heart & Community Spirit to Noblesville Real Estate

Photographer / Stephanie Duncan

Sarah Colón

Sarah Colón earned her real estate license in 1999, shortly after graduating from Purdue University. She began her career working with builders, specializing in new construction homes — a foundation that continues to serve her clients well today. In 2006, she brought her license into active practice, assisting both buyers and sellers with their real estate goals.

“My background in new construction has been an incredible advantage for clients interested in building,” Colón explains. “Because I already understand the process, I can help make it much smoother and less stressful.”

Originally from South Dakota, Colón has called Noblesville home for more than 26 years. She and her husband are proud parents of four children — two Noblesville High School graduates and two still enrolled in Noblesville Schools. Deeply connected to her community, Colón has made Noblesville not only her home but also the heart of her professional life.

Known for her unwavering dedication, she advocates fiercely for her clients.

“I fight hard to protect my clients’ best interests and investments,” she says. “This process can feel overwhelming, so I do everything I can to carry that weight for them.”

Her clients frequently become friends, thanks to her genuine care and personal approach.

“People are far more than just a transaction to me,” she says. “Building lasting relationships is the most rewarding part of my work.”

Colón embraces the ever-changing nature of real estate, thriving on new challenges and opportunities.

“I love that every experience is different,” she shares. “Being part of someone’s journey into a new home is a privilege I never take for granted.”

Giving back to the community is equally important to her. She proudly sponsors local events such as the Noblesville BrewFest and Savor Noblesville, and she supports Noblesville Youth Baseball, Noblesville Millers Athletics, and Noblesville Parks & Recreation. For Colón, community involvement is simply another way of investing in the place she and her family call home.

Sarah Floyd

Sarah Floyd grew up in Monroeville, just south of Fort Wayne. After spending time in Ohio and Oklahoma, she moved to Noblesville in 2016 and earned her real estate license the following year. Her passion for real estate sparked years earlier when she watched her father flip homes, giving her early insight into renovations and what makes a property truly shine.

What began as a part-time pursuit quickly became a full-time calling.

“I realized early on that real estate isn’t something you can do halfway,” Floyd says. “I jumped in with everything I had, determined to succeed.”

Floyd is known for her problem-solving mindset and her ability to ease the stress of the buying and selling process.

“No two transactions are ever the same,” she notes. “I love finding solutions and ensuring my clients feel cared for every step of the way.”

Like Colón, Floyd emphasizes personal connection, often staying in touch with families long after the closing table.

“That’s what I love most,” she says. “It’s not just about the deal — it’s about becoming part of someone’s story.”

Family remains her greatest priority, and balancing work with raising her children is central to her life. At the same time, Floyd is deeply engaged in the community, contributing to Noblesville schools through PTO involvement, monthly events for teachers, and sponsorships. She and Colón frequently team up to support local fundraisers such as BrewFest, sharing their belief that community presence is about belonging, not just visibility.

Together

Together, Sarah Colón and Sarah Floyd are better known as Two Sarahs and a Sold Sign.

After meeting in 2018 as colleagues, they quickly became close friends — bonding over their shared love of music, their careers, and even the “H” in their names.

More importantly, they share the same values: family, community, persistence and genuine connection. Between them, they bring nearly 36 years of combined experience, consistently ranking among top producers in the area. Trusted by clients and respected by peers, they’ve built reputations not just as skilled professionals but as true advocates for the people they serve.

“When you work with us, you’re not just hiring a real estate agent,” Colón says. “You’re gaining someone who is fully invested in your life and your family.”

You can find them at their office in Downtown Noblesville at 823 Conner Street on the Square.

• Sarah Colón, eXp Realty – Serving buyers and sellers in Noblesville and surrounding areas. Contact her at 317-709-5201 or sarah.colon@exprealty.com.
• Sarah Floyd, eXp Realty – Helping clients across Noblesville and nearby communities. Reach her at 317-556-0423 or sarah.floyd@exprealty.com.