Olthof Homes Stands Apart With a Personal Touch to the Building Process

Olthof Homes arrived in the Indianapolis market in 2017, the product of a proud three-generation, family-run business that has been building quality single-family homes, townhomes and paired villas since 1961. Founded by Fritz and Karen Olthof, the company started with Fritz’s hands-on approach to home construction, a personal touch that remains a hallmark of Olthof Homes today. Their legacy is carried on by their four sons, Scot, Todd, Dennis and Fritz, and grandson, Matt, all of whom hold construction management degrees from Purdue University and oversee different areas of the business.

“Being a family-owned business originally from northwest Indiana and starting in a new market was challenging to build our brand initially, but it has been such a rewarding experience,” says Lisa McCleskey, division manager at Olthof Homes. “Upon arrival in the Indianapolis market, we were excited to show a new customer base all about our homes and how we prioritize customer service in every way possible. We are proud of our homes and we give top-of-the-line effort to make sure we serve our customers well.”

With their customer-first philosophy, Olthof Homes’ process ensures that buyers are guided every step of the way, from initial consultation to post-move-in support. Their dedication and service has earned them accolades and a loyal following in the Indianapolis area – and now Plainfield.

The Bo-Mar development is Olthof Homes’ first community in Plainfield.

“One thing we love about Plainfield is the excitement we hear from business owners, realtors and educators,” McCleskey says. “They are all excited about where Plainfield is going, and that makes us excited to be a small part of that movement.”

Olthof Homes developments emphasize thoughtful planning, offering a mix of architectural styles and floor plans to cater to various lifestyles, whether for growing families, professionals, or retirees seeking comfort and convenience.

With appealing exterior character, energy efficiency, trusted methods, creative floor plans and comfortable living spaces, Olthof Homes stands apart. The company’s reputation is built on delivering not just houses, but homes that foster a sense of belonging and meet the diverse needs of today’s homeowners. With a team of warm, eager-to-help professionals ready to give you support, advice and solutions, Olthof Homes is ready to guide customers through each step of the new-home building journey with ease and enjoyment.

One hallmark of Olthof Homes is its focus on quality and innovation. Each home reflects a meticulous attention to detail, blending timeless craftsmanship with contemporary features. Open-concept layouts, energy-efficient systems and customizable options ensure that homeowners can personalize their spaces while enjoying modern functionality. The use of premium materials and sustainable practices underscores Olthof Homes’ commitment to durability and environmental responsibility.

Because Olthof Homes is family owned – not part of a large corporation – their clients never become a number.

“We know our customers by name,” McCleskey says. “The owners of our company still make random visits and walk through our homes. They want to make sure that we are delivering homes under our core values: Humbly serve, Own it, Memorable experience, Efficient. Our pricing is also pretty straightforward, as we don’t do pricing swings according to the time of year. In the end, a customer will select the floor plan they love, but once they love our floor plan, then the rest of the package we offer is pretty tough to beat compared to anywhere else.”

Olthof Homes also serves these core values by getting involved in the community and creating a culture that encompasses better living, not just for employees, but also for everyone the homebuilding company serves.

“We joined the Plainfield Chamber of Commerce to get involved,” says McCleskey. “There is always something going on in the area and lots of opportunities to serve. Last year, for the first time ever, our company entered a float in a community parade. It was a lot of work and fun, but it paid off because we won the Best Theme – ‘Our Plainfield Era, Then and Now.’”

The float used photos from the 1960s when Olthof first started building homes, and then displayed photos of what their homes look like now.

“Those of us working for Olthof Homes in 2025 feel so blessed and honored to be able to carry this legacy forward into Plainfield,” she says. “We will definitely be looking for more opportunities to serve the community throughout the year.”

If McCleskey could add a fifth value to the company’s core values, it would be the word ‘truth.”

Some of our phrases are, ‘You belong here’ – we adopted this and sometimes you’ll see it at the entrance to our communities, or on a wall in a welcome center, because everyone is welcome,” she says. “In this world, more than ever, people need to know there is a place where they belong. Another phrase is, ‘Live better.’ Let’s not all just white-knuckle it through another challenging news cycle, but let’s live better where we are, impacting our neighbors and community right from our own homes. That is where true change starts.”

The homebuilding company continues to expand and build new communities throughout northwest Indiana and the Indianapolis area. Looking ahead in 2025, Olthof Homes will be rolling out a new community in Greenfield called Evergreen Estates.

You can contact Olthof Homes at 317-999-9392, olthofhomes.com, and on social media @OltholfHomesIndianapolis (Facebook) and @OlthofHomesIndy (Instagram).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

MULTIPLE WIDGETS ON THE SAME PAGE

Latest Hendricks County Stories

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Send me your media kit!

hbspt.forms.create({ portalId: "6486003", formId: "5ee2abaf-81d9-48a9-a10d-de06becaa6db" });