Photographer: Michael Durr
The secret to a great local pizza place is having a wide variety of pizza options and other entrées to choose from. Everything also needs to taste fresh and delicious.
Customers want to know they are getting excellent crust, which is not just the heart of the pizza but also one of the most important ingredients. The toppings also need to be fresh, and above all, taste delicious.
Mama Nita’s Pizza, which opened recently, meets that criteria and the staff ensure they have a large selection of other food options.
Patrick Finn, co-owner of Mama Nita’s, 11007 N. Allisonville Road, says he and his staff are looking forward to being your local pizza shop. He believes Fishers is an ideal location for another successful restaurant in the Mama Nita’s lineup.
“We are one of three Mama Nita locations,” Finn says. “The first one was established in 2008 in New Palestine, and we opened the second location in Greenfield in 2017. Now we are here in Fishers. We found an opening here and believe it will be a good fit with good food and a great environment.”
The pizza at Mama Nita’s is outstanding, but that’s not their only delicious item. They offer a wide variety of menu options.
“We specialize in a variety of subs and wings, as well as our pizza,” Finn says. “We get a lot of requests for our chicken bacon ranch pizza and our bacon cheeseburger pizza.”
Finn says that the staff at Mama Nita’s has already made many new friends.
“The community response has been great,” Finn says. “The customers are positive and supportive. We enjoy the Fishers atmosphere and the welcoming local businesses around us.”
Customers already have their favorites. Finn stressed that the Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza, the BBQ chicken and The Cinnamon Roll Pizza are frequently ordered.
Finn’s personal favorites are the wings and the Buffalo Chicken Pizza.
“We also have a good salad variety and offer appetizers, such as made-from-scratch Potato Skins, Mozzarella Sticks and Chicken Fingers,” he adds.
Mama Nita’s also features Hoagies, Calzones and Pasta. Buffet specials are also offered, as well as delivery service.
The staff at Mama Nita’s is very welcoming, making you feel right at home.
“We are all about family here at Mama Nita’s,” Finn says. “We are locally owned and operated.”
Finn has been pleased with all the positive feedback he has received from the Fishers community so far.
“I would like to thank all our neighbors and other business for their support,” Finn says. “And to all our new and returning costumers: a huge thank you.”
Mama Nita’s is located at 11007 Allisonville Road. Give them a call at 317-598-5040.